Flashover Friday

How much should a non- fire service related degree count during promotional time. Should it have any merit at all? Should you even get paid extra for having a non-related degree?

3 Comments

  • HallwaySledge says:

    Oh boy. Here we go. I’m one of those “educated” firemen with a college degree. I earned mine in Criminal Justice and Law Enforcement Administration, with a minor in Industrial Safety. I chose that as my major because inside the College of Law Enforcement there were a handful of fire classes, mostly focusing on arson investigation. At the time I was in school there was no such thing as a Bachelor’s degree in Fire Science, there weren’t even Associate degree programs yet. The only thing close was Oklahoma State’s program. Anyway, I do not get paid anything extra for my degree even though I am told it makes me a better all-around firefighter and perhaps gives me a bit of an edge for promotional opportunities. My department does pay guys with a 2-year Associate’s degree in Fire Science an extra $500, however. Here’s my rub with that. The Associate degrees in Fire Science in my area consist of everything our state Firefighter II curriculum includes plus a smattering from the Fire Officer I. So, if I have to be at the minimum a Firefighter II to even be on the job and I already have my complete Fire Officer I cert and am almost complete with Fire Officer II, don’t I already meet all those requirements? If the Associate’s degree is the base knowledge for being on the job what is the degree giving the department extra? What are they paying for? That’s just my area and my department. Maybe other areas degrees offer more expanded education above and beyond what local firefighters are already being trained to. I don’t know. But around here, I think it’s a joke.

  • anchorpoint1 says:

    Wow Sledge how long ago was that? Just kidding. Our police force had a problem with colleges giving credit for OJE. SO if the work with a psych patient once they got psychology course credit. 3 credit hours in the bank. They fixed that.
    OK, moving on. I do believe a college degree should be required for promotion. Just like in the real world if you want a job you need a degree. It does not prove knowledge, it proves commitment. It shows that you make goals and achieve them.
    Well that was short, Stay safe.

  • Emmit says:

    Yes, a degree should count for something within any career. Higher education degrees often bring a more cognitively developed individual who has a more rounded worldly view and approach to many things in life. One of the many things you’ll learn in (and about) college regards following directions. Often an individual must do their own research (with given resources), develop conclusions and organize them into a project for the given subject and professor. Sure, many people are capable of this away from the colleage setting, but one “learns” to do this in college. We can always find exceptions when we seek them, but in general, college educated individuals bring a more cognatively developed, well rounded and professional individual than those that did not seek a higher level of learning. It is also plausible that college educations can speak to the motivation of an individual that seeks more vs. stops right out of high school or GED. College is not for everyone and college does not define everyone, but there is a reason for schools of higher learning and they should speak for something. With regards to whether or not the degree should be related to the profession, one would hope that it would be the desire of the individual to focus their education in the area they choose to pursue. It’s definately more beneficial and possibly should be used to scrutinize two closely related individuals, but I do not believe it should a singular requirement. A college degree should help you get your foot in the door, but it is the individual that learns to stay inside.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

background image Blogger Img

Marques Bush

Firefighter Basics launched in February 2009 after Founder/Editor Marques Bush was looking for a way to express himself and share his experiences with brother and sister firefighters. Shortly after founding the site Marques spoke with several trusted friends and ask them to come on board and contribute also. Firefighter Basics is a dedicated group of firefighters who strive everyday to practice what they preach about Training, Safety, and Tradition.  We can be reached at firefighterbasics@gmail.com

FE Talk: Humpday Hangout

Recent Posts
Words Matter September 4, 2015
Freelancing August 27, 2015
Ultrahazardous August 25, 2015
Aggressive Destruction August 24, 2015
Estimating The Stretch August 21, 2015
Comments
John Vanatta
Words Matter
Dave, I don't know why that is the "default response". I am not a regular ISFSI member, and I have no reason to defend or attack them as an organization. Maybe my response was poorly worded, or there is a misunderstanding. The instructor from my class did not mince any words-rescue is the priority, use…
2015-09-05 00:35:00
anchorpoint1
Words Matter
Thank you for your comment John. I'm happy to hear you got the message clear by attending the class, but there are an estimated 1.2 million firefighters in the USA. They are not all going to be able to attend the class. Many will learn from people like you who attended the class and bring…
2015-09-04 23:49:29
Dave LeBlanc
Words Matter
Just curious....why is the default response when someone disagrees with what ISFSI puts out that they have not read/studied/learned enough?
2015-09-04 22:39:25
John Vanatta
Words Matter
I attended the SLICE-RS class and the instructor course, and recently passed the info on to my dept. I disagree that ISFSI or the SLICE-RS program are as sloppy as implied. I walked away from the classes with an extremely clear understanding that rescue is always the priority, straight/solid streams are necessary for the exterior…
2015-09-04 22:03:39
Sandy Lasa
Words Matter
This whole so called new phenomenon from NIST as been around for years. The Fire Service has gone insane over this. The only new info that has come out and been verified is that fires DO burn hotter now than before. Everything else has stayed the same. It comes down to training and mastering your…
2015-09-04 13:21:30

Follow Firefighter Basics

FireEMS Blogs eNewsletter

Sign-up to receive our free monthly eNewsletter

LATEST FIREFIGHTER NEWS

HOT FORUM DISCUSSIONS

LATEST ON FIRE ENGINEERING

FEATURED DISCUSSIONS